When it comes to improving decision-making and performance, two strategies are often discussed: providing more support, positive feedback, and cooperation – or offering more challenge, testing, and experience. I argue both can be accomplished together.
Choosing Challenges Over Easy Wins
Consider this scenario: Would you prefer competing against an expert, facing challenges, and learning from the experience, or compete against someone where you clearly have the upper-hand? Most individuals lean towards the former, seeking challenges, gains, and knowledge.
For example, many women basketball teams will have some practices against men so their actual games against the competition seem less physically demanding. Even kids competing seek a greater challenge when they know parents are letting them win.
The Crucial Role of Culture
Achieving a balance between support and challenge hinges on fostering a culture of learning, growth, and experience rather than one centered on failure and win-lose outcomes.
Let’s look at the example of elite college admissions to schools like Havard and Yale where only about 10% of applicants are accepted. Instead of solely pursuing prestige and competition, individuals should also weigh factors like scholarships, specialized programs, diversity, and campus life when making decisions Schools like Cal Tech, Johns Hopkins, Northeastern, Carnegie Melon, Berkeley, Georgia Tech and University of Texas at Austin are examples of competitive choices.
Efforts to Foster a Positive Culture
In order to balance support and challenge, we need to identify and evaluate alternatives. Comparing resources, probability, potential results, and fit can add to success without the stress of win-lose.
The alternatives must be evaluated within the context of individual needs and goals. For example, retirement portfolios must balance income, growth, risk, probability, inheritance and other goals. My view is that we can afford more risk as we age, as expenses decline and investments increase.
Testing and Learning from Experience
There are more opportunities to test decisions than we often consider. Testing outcomes with simple models, evaluating alternative behaviors, risks, probabilities, and time frames contribute to informed decision-making.
Experience and practice reduce the challenges and provide support for future success. Many training programs are based on continued training, mentoring and trial and error. Even some aspects of surgery can be practiced on a computer. Hospitals with the most activity in providing a particular service have better results. Making the first souffle seldom succeeds, but practice can make them delectable. It is also beneficial to grow gradually and increase difficulty as you progress. For instance, I was surprised to learn that swimming is more difficult to develop conditioning in than running.
Setting Goals and Priorities
What are your goals and priorities? Financial versus social; long-term versus short-term; excellence versus perfection; development versus success; individual versus group. It is important to consider these dimensions and avoid conflicts and confusion.
Passion as a Success Factor
Passion is highlighted as an underestimated factor in success, yet it provides extra motivation, enables risk-taking, and often yields greater satisfaction upon success.
Understanding and Using Algorithms Better
We use algorithms but could understand and use them better. Don’t be afraid of math, probability and analyzing risk. Developing and using proven processes for activities can add to success. Even simple behaviors like eating, driving, exercise and health can be improved. I’m diabetic and know the guidelines, but sometimes I don’t follow them.
Innovation versus Experience
It’s important to evaluate the need for innovation versus experience. Complex problems frequently require innovation, while detailed procedures require more experience, as in, for example, open-heart surgery versus car repair.
When do you need to develop new solutions versus execute effectively? What is the balance between excellence and perfection in an effort? I argue we can frequently be more effective if we are striving for excellence.
Understanding the support and challenge game in management is key. Develop tools, consider alternatives, aim for win-win situations, measure outcomes, and set priorities. Ultimately, fostering an effective culture and open processes is essential for effective problem-solving, with a simple reminder to see the glass as half-full rather than half-empty.
Let’s start a conversation – no matter what stage you are in with your business. As an exercise, tell us how you have better managed challenges. Then, tell us what areas you to need focus on in order to see improvement.
Dr. Bert Shlensky , President of StartupConnection.net, earned a PhD from the Sloan School of Management at M.I.T., mentored a few thousand clients at Score and in his own practice, grew Sure Fit products from $50 million to $150 million in sales, including $60 million of direct internet sales, was President of WestPoint Pepperell’s Apparel Fabrics Business and headed the $400 million Culet Shirt Group. Dr. Bert knows what works and can help lead your company to greater profitability and success. For a free initial consult, reach out at bshlenksy@startupconnection.net or 914-632-6977.